When autumn arrives, everything, from lattes to candles and even skincare, seems to get a pumpkin spice makeover. This DIY pumpkin spice body butter is the perfect way to bring that cozy, fall-inspired aroma into your daily self-care routine.
✨ Get 12 Free Holiday Diffuser Blends — Printable PDF
Instantly make your home smell like Christmas with these festive, ready-to-use recipes.
With its fluffy, whipped texture and nourishing blend of shea butter and natural oils, this fall-scented body butter keeps skin soft and hydrated while wrapping you in the warm, spicy scent of the season.
It combines everything you love about fall in one jar. And the best part? It’s so easy to make at home!
If you enjoy natural self-care, you’ll love this homemade treat, packed with skin-loving butters and oils, plus a blend of essential oils for that authentic autumn aroma.
Table of Contents
Affiliate Disclosure: Some links on this site are affiliate links. I may earn a small commission if you purchase through them, at no extra cost to you. See the full affiliate disclosure.
Why You’ll Love This Pumpkin Spice Whipped Body Butter Recipe
This isn’t just any whipped body butter – it’s fall in a jar.
These are just a few reasons why you’re sure to love making and using it:
Cozy Autumn Scent: A blend of cinnamon, clove, nutmeg, and ginger essential oils creates that classic pumpkin spice aroma.
Ultra-Moisturizing: Shea butter and carrier oils deeply nourish dry skin, making it ideal for cooler months without that heavy feeling.
Fluffy Whipped Texture: Light, airy, and luxurious, it feels like applying a soft, scented cloud to your skin.
DIY and Customizable: Control the ingredients, adjust the scent strength, and even add a hint of mica for a festive glow.
Perfect for Gifting: Packaged in a jar, this homemade fall-scented body butter makes a thoughtful handmade gift for friends and family during the holidays.
This pumpkin spice whipped body butter deeply moisturizes the skin with rich butters and oils while leaving a warm, cozy scent perfect for fall.
Ingredients For Pumpkin Spice Whipped Body Butter Recipe
Here’s what you’ll need to make and scent whipped body butter:
½ cup Shea Butter – The star ingredient in this recipe, rich and creamy, shea butter gives the body butter its luxurious base and deeply nourishes dry skin, which is so vital as cooler, drier autumn air arrives.
6 tablespoons Carrier Oil – Helps balance the texture and adds extra hydration, creating a silky-smooth whipped blend. Good options include Sweet Almond (light and silky), Jojoba (closest to skin’s natural oils), or Fractionated Coconut (absorbs quickly).
¼ teaspoon Orange Mica (optional) – Adds a soft golden glow to your butter, giving it a festive autumn look. Skippable if you prefer a natural cream color.
5 drops Pumpkin Spice Essential Oil blend – Warm and spicy, this scent is the heart of this pumpkin spice whipped body butter recipe.
Optional boosters
1 teaspoon Arrowroot Powder to cut down greasiness if necessary
1/2 teaspoon Vitamin E for a longer shelf life
Note: You can mix two carrier oils. If you decide to do this, add 3 tablespoons of each for a total of 6 tablespoons.
Batch Size And Variations
This recipe makes about 8 ounces, enough to fill one 8-ounce jar or two 4-ounce jars.
To scale it up or down for gift giving
- Half batch (4 ounces): 1/4 cup shea butter, 3 tbsp carrier oil, halve all optional add-ins and essential oils.
- Double batch (16 ounces): 1 cup shea butter, 12 tbsp (3/4 cup) carrier oil, double essential oils and add-ins.
- Tip: Whip large batches in a stand mixer to keep airiness.
- Keep essential oils proportional
Butter Swaps and How They Affect the Texture
Cocoa butter: firmer, adds a chocolate scent. Result is denser; chill a bit less and whip a bit longer.
Mango butter: lighter and less greasy. Whips very fluffy; great for spring.
Start with the same measurements, then adjust whip time to get soft peaks.
How To Make Pumpkin Spice Whipped Body Butter Step-by-Step Instructions
Melt The Shea Butter And Carrier Oil
Heat the shea butter and carrier oil using a double boiler.
To do this, add the two ingredients to a heat-safe bowl. Place the bowl over a pot with 1–2 inches of simmering water. Stir gently occasionally until smooth and fully combined.
Avoid direct heat or high heat. If the butter gets too hot, it can grain later.
Pro Tip: Aim for “just melted,” not hot. Gentle melting on low heat blends the fats evenly so the final texture whips up smooth and stays stable. This step is where your whipped body butter gets its silky texture, setting the stage for the fluffiest results.
Chill Until Hardened
When both ingredients have fully melted and combined, place the bowl in the refrigerator for about 30 minutes, or until the edges begin to harden and the center feels firm yet scoopable.
This chilling phase is key to getting that irresistible whipped texture. You want it set enough to whip, but still soft enough for the beaters to sink in. A partial set traps tiny air bubbles when whipped, giving you that fluffy, cloud-like texture.
Tip: If you forget and it hardens too much, let it sit at room temperature for a few minutes or set the bowl over warm water for 30 seconds to soften.to soften slightly before whipping.
Whip Until Light And Fluffy
Using a hand mixer or stand mixer, whip the chilled mixture for 5–7 minutes, until it becomes airy, smooth, and doubles in volume.
Start on low, then increase to medium-high for 2–4 minutes. Scrape down the bowl once or twice.
This is where the magic happens – the mixture transforms into a silky, cloud-like body butter.
The body butter should look like whipped cream and hold soft peaks.
Don’t overwhip to the point of collapse or greasiness. Stop when it looks airy and velvety.
If it’s too soft and soupy after whipping, chill for another 10 minutes and whip again. If it’s too firm, whip in 1–2 teaspoons more carrier oil.
Tip: For the fluffiest texture, pause halfway through to scrape down the sides of the bowl and then continue whipping.
Add The Pumpkin Spice Essential Oil Blend
When you’ve finished whipping and are happy with the texture, add in the pumpkin spice essential oil blend.
Beat again for a minute to distribute the scent evenly through the body butter.
Tip: Always add essential oils after whipping. This preserves the aroma and reduces exposure to heat, which damages the oil’s properties.
Add Mica Powder (Optional)
If you’d like a festive touch, sprinkle in a little bit of orange mica and whip again until fully blended. This gives your butter a beautiful, warm fall glow.
Mica adds a soft, fall tint without staining skin when used sparingly.
Tip: Start with a tiny amount of mica. You can always add more for a deeper color but you cannot remove it if you add too much.
Transfer Into A Jar And Store
Spoon the finished body butter into a clean, dry airtight 8-oz jar. Store at room temperature in a cool, dry place. If your home is warm, you may prefer to keep it in the fridge to prevent melting.
Tip: A decorative jar makes it gift-ready and perfect for holiday baskets.
Tips To Make The Perfect Pumpkin Spice Whipped Body Butter
Making whipped body butter is simple, but these few tips can make the process even smoother and your final product even fluffier:
- Use a mixer for the best texture. A hand mixer or stand mixer will give you that light, airy, whipped consistency. Whisking by hand won’t achieve the same result.
- Don’t overheat the shea butter. Gentle melting keeps all the natural skin-loving properties intact. Always use a double boiler instead of microwaving.
- Chill just enough – not too much. The mixture should be firm but not rock solid before whipping. If it’s too soft, it won’t whip properly. If it’s too hard, let it sit out for a few minutes and try again.
- Customize your carrier oil. Each oil has its own texture and benefits — try jojoba for a fast-absorbing finish, almond for a silky glide, or coconut oil for extra richness.
- Go easy on the essential oils. A little goes a long way! Too much cinnamon or clove can overpower the scent and may feel irritating on sensitive skin.
- Store in a cool, dry place. Whipped body butter can melt in hot weather. If that happens, just re-chill and re-whip it back into shape.
- Use clean hands or a spoon to scoop. This helps prevent introducing bacteria into your jar, keeping your butter fresher for longer.
Troubleshooting Tips When Making Body Butter
The body butter is too soft and or runny: Chill the bowl 10–15 minutes, then whip again. If your room is warm, add another 1–2 teaspoons of shea butter to harden the mixture.
The resultant product is too hard or too waxy: Add 1–2 teaspoons of carrier oil and whip again until it becomes fluffy. For the next batch, use a lighter carrier oil such as jojoba or grapeseed.
The body butter develops a grainy texture after a day or two: This is usually due to overheating at high heat, resulting in uneven cooling. To make it smooth, melt it gently again on low heat and repeat the chilling and whipping steps.
The product feels oily or greasy on your skin: Whip in 1 teaspoon arrowroot powder and test again.
Use a lighter carrier oil blend next time (50% jojoba or grapeseed).
The scent is too strong: Add another 1–2 tablespoons of melted shea + oil (cooled to room temp), then re-whip.
The scent is too light: Add 1–2 more drops total of the spice blend, then whip for 15 seconds or layer with a complementary vanilla or orange essential oil, staying within safe limits.
The body butter loses its fluff later: This happens if you leave it out. Warm bases don’t hold air. To fluff it, chill until edges firm, then re-whip.
Pumpkin Spice Body Butter Customization Ideas
One of the best parts of making your own whipped body butter is that you can customize it for the season or your personal style. Here are some creative ways to put your own spin on this Pumpkin Spice Whipped Body Butter:
Fall-Inspired Variations
Halloween Glow: Add a touch of purple or black mica powder for a spooky, magical effect — perfect for October.
Extra Cozy Scents: Blend in a drop of vanilla or sweet orange essential oil to soften the spice notes and create a warm, comforting aroma.
Subtle Shimmer: A pinch of cosmetic-grade glitter or shimmer mica can give your body butter a festive sparkle for fall parties or nights out.
Winter-Inspired Variations
Peppermint Mocha Butter: Swap the spice blend for peppermint essential oil with a hint of cocoa butter for a fresh and sweet holiday treat.
Vanilla Chai Butter: Blend vanilla and cardamom essential oils with cinnamon and clove for a cozy, chai-inspired twist.
Frosted Look: Use silver or icy blue mica to give your whipped body butter a frosted, wintery appearance.
Tip: Always use skin-safe mica or glitter intended for cosmetics. Never use craft glitter, which can irritate the skin.
How to Use Body Butter For Best Results
Using whipped body butter is all about indulging your skin with moisture while enjoying that warm pumpkin spice aroma. Here’s how to get the most out of it:
Apply After Showering: Smooth it onto damp skin to lock in hydration. The butter melts beautifully into warm skin.
Focus on Dry Areas: Massage into elbows, knees, heels, and hands — anywhere that tends to feel rough in cooler weather.
A Little Goes A Long Way: This body butter is rich and concentrated, so start with a small amount and add more as needed.
Make it a Nighttime Routine: Use it as part of your nighttime routine to wake up with soft, nourished skin.
Pamper Yourself with a Special Treat: For an at-home spa moment, warm a small amount between your palms and massage slowly into the skin, breathing in the cozy autumn scent. Get more fall home spa ideas for a day of pampering and self-care.
Pumpkin Spice Body Butter Storage & Shelf Life
A little care goes a long way in keeping homemade pumpkin spice whipped body butter fresh and fluffy. These tips will help keep your fall skincare treat smelling and feeling good longer.
Store the body butter in a clean, airtight jar at room temperature, away from direct sunlight and heat. If your home is very warm, store it in the fridge to prevent melting.
Use a clean spoon or spatula to scoop out the butter. This prevents bacteria from getting into the jar, which causes premature spoilage.
If the whipped body butter melts and solidifies, re-whip it with your mixer to regain the fluffy texture.
Homemade body butter typically lasts 3–6 months, provided that you keep it clean and sterile. For an even longer shelf life, add a few drops of natural Vitamin E oil, which acts as a preservative.
Gift & Presentation Ideas
Mix and match these ideas to transform your homemade pumpkin spice whipped body butter into a special, thoughtful gift that is sure to be appreciated.
Choose the jar: Scoop the body butter into one 8-ounce or two 4-ounce amber or frosted glass jars for gifting.
Label the jar: Add a simple kraft label with the name, scent, and made-on date. Include a quick-use note on the back.
Add a spoon: Tie a small wooden cosmetic spoon or spatula with twine or ribbon at the side of or on top of the jar.
Dress it up: Wrap the lid with plaid ribbon, tuck in a sprig of dried orange peel or cinnamon stick, and add a gift tag.
Make a set: Pair the body butter with a matching sugar scrub or a bar of soap. Use the same pumpkin spice scent family for a cohesive gift.
Color theme: If you used mica, match your label and ribbon to the tint, like copper, gold, or pumpkin orange.
Gift box: Place crinkled paper in a small kraft box, nestle the jar, and add a printed recipe card.
Tip: Handmade body butters are perfect stocking stuffers, hostess gifts, or self-care treats for friends who love all things cozy and seasonal.
More Fall DIYs
3 Pumpkin Spice Recipes:
- DIY Body Scrub: Slough off dry skin with this cozy, homemade fall-scented sugar scrub, then follow with your body butter for the softest glow.
- Sugar Scrub Bars: Buff away rough patches with homemade sugar scrub bars packed with warm pumpkin spice and skin-loving oils. Rinse to reveal smooth, glowing skin that smells like fall.
- Melt And Pour Soap Bars: Make quick, beginner-friendly fall soap bars with seasonal scents. Melt, scent, pour, and you’re done in under an hour.
Fall Soy Candle In A Jar: Set the mood while you moisturize. This simple soy candle tutorial walks you through wicks, fragrance load, and clean burns.
Fall Foaming Hand Soap With Essential Oils: Easy to make with just 3 ingredients and a special pump bottle, this all-natural, fall-scented foaming hand soap is gentle on skin.
Halloween Soap Bars: Pour bright orange soap into a jack-o’-lantern mold and add a kid-safe scent to make these Jack-O’-Lantern soap bars. They are fun for parties and trick-or-treat favors.
Fall Room Sprays: Spritz your space with crisp, cozy notes in seconds with homemade fall room sprays that use assorted seasonal scent combos like orange spice and vanilla chai.
Fall-Scented Potpourri: Fill your home with a natural autumn aroma using dried citrus, spices, and pinecones. Display fall scented potpourri in bowls on the table for a gentle, long-lasting scent.
There’s something magical about creating your own skincare that feels both indulgent and personal. This DIY pumpkin spice whipped body butter combines everything we love about fall – cozy aromas, nourishing textures, and a little seasonal fun. It comes together fast, scales easily, makes great seasonal gifts, and is the perfect way to bring a touch of autumn warmth into everyday life.
Pumpkin Spice Body Butter FAQs
Can I use cocoa or mango butter instead of shea butter?
Yes, you can. Cocoa butter makes a firmer, denser butter with a light chocolate scent. Mango butter is lighter and less greasy, and whips up fluffier than shea butter. Start with the same amounts mentioned in the recipe, then adjust chill and whip time to reach soft peaks.
What carrier oil is best for DIY whipped body butter?
For a light feel, pick jojoba or grapeseed. For very dry skin, use sweet almond or avocado. For warm climates or shipping, choose fractionated coconut oil because it stays liquid and stable.
Do I need to add a preservative to my homemade body butter?
No. This recipe doesn’t use any water, so there’s no need to add any preservatives. Generally, it’s water that causes premature spoilage. Keep water out of the jar and use clean, dry hands or a spatula to scoop to extend the life of the body butter.
Why did my body butter turn grainy?
Shea can crystallize if overheated or cooled too slowly. Gently remelt until just liquid, chill until the edges firm, then re-whip. Next time, avoid high heat and cool promptly.
Can I use any other color dye?
The mica color is optional. You can leave it uncolored or use a tiny pinch of skin-safe mineral pigments. Avoid food coloring as it can stain.
